Report card season comes round three times a year, and with it the same question: how do you write thirty fair, varied and useful comments in a single evening? A good report card comment fits in one or two sentences, yet it is read by the student, by their family and sometimes by the people deciding on their next steps. This guide offers a simple method, then a bank of examples sorted by student profile, by time of year and by subject, ready to reuse and adjust.
What a report card comment is for
A report card sums up the work of a term. The comment complements the average: it says what the number does not, how the student works, what is improving and what they need to do next. Three qualities make the difference.
- It is specific: “progress in written work” tells the student more than “good term”.
- It is about the work, not the person: write “homework is not handed in”, not “lazy student”.
- It points forward: a concrete piece of advice, however short, turns an observation into a goal for next term.
The three-step method
Most effective comments follow the same structure, which you only need to keep in mind to write quickly.
- An observation about results: the level reached, a trend, a success or a specific difficulty.
- A word about attitude: effort, participation, consistency, independence.
- A piece of advice or encouragement: what to keep doing, strengthen or change.
Before you start, keep the term's grades in front of you and, if you have them, the remarks left on the students' papers: they supply the specific facts that make a comment credible. Write the comments for students whose situation is clear-cut first, then come back to the ones that need more nuance.
Example comments by student profile
The examples below deliberately use no name and the third person, as most report cards do. Mix them, shorten them, replace the generic terms with the skill or topic concerned: a comment copied word for word onto ten report cards is quickly spotted.
Highly committed student, excellent results
- An excellent term. Work is rigorous and knowledge secure. Keep it up.
- Outstanding results, the fruit of serious, consistent work. Contributions enrich the lessons.
- Very good overall. Analysis is perceptive and well written. Maintain these high standards.
- A brilliant term, driven by genuine curiosity. Reasoning skills are a real strength.
- Work of very high quality, written and oral. Aim for even greater depth.
- A driving force in the class, with excellent results. Congratulations on this commitment.
Good student who could aim higher
- A good term. The basics are secure; taking more risks when speaking in class would help progress.
- Satisfactory results and serious work. The next step is to develop reasoning in more depth.
- Good overall, but capable of more. Higher standards in written work are needed.
- Consistent work and solid results. More active participation would be welcome.
- A good level, sometimes let down by a lack of precision. Check work more carefully.
- A successful term. To move up a level, answers need to be developed and justified.
Average results, conscientious work
- Real effort, not yet reflected in the results. Persevere and review working methods.
- The commitment is there. Lessons need to be learned more thoroughly to pay off.
- Results are still fragile, but effort is constant. Don't hesitate to ask questions.
- Careful work. Method still needs strengthening, especially in organising answers.
- Satisfactory overall. Key skills need reinforcing through regular practice.
- A fair term. The knowledge is there; applying it still needs to improve.
Struggling student
- A difficult term. The basics need revisiting; the help offered in class should be taken up.
- Significant difficulties. Regular work each evening, even briefly, will lead to progress.
- Results are below the expected standard. Review the key concepts and ask for help as soon as something is unclear.
- Difficulties persist, but some successes show progress is possible. Keep going.
- A challenging term. Going back over the method sheets and redoing the corrected exercises would help.
- Understanding is still fragile. Making use of the individual support on offer will help rebuild confidence.
Chatty or easily distracted
- Real ability, but chatting gets in the way of concentration and results.
- Behaviour in class needs to change: attention wanders far too often.
- Satisfactory results, which could be much better with more focus.
- Enthusiasm to channel: contributions should help the lesson, not disrupt it.
- Work is uneven and behaviour in class too unsettled. A real change is expected.
Not working enough
- Independent work is insufficient: lessons are not learned and homework is not always done.
- Results do not reflect ability. It is time to get down to serious work.
- Too much homework not handed in. Consistency is essential to make progress.
- Natural ability, but minimal effort. Results have suffered this term.
- Effort is too low. There is still time to turn things around.
Quiet or reserved student
- Serious, careful work. Now is the time to speak up more in class.
- Good written results. Contributing more orally would show this knowledge off.
- Quiet but diligent. Contributions, when they come, are relevant: more of them, please.
- Work is consistent. Growing in confidence when speaking is the next goal.
Improving results
- Clear progress this term, thanks to more consistent work. Keep going in this direction.
- A pleasing improvement, both in written work and in attitude. Keep it up.
- The effort is paying off: results are rising. This progress now needs to be sustained.
- An encouraging term. Method is improving; the next step is greater consistency.
- Noticeable progress in written work. Well done for persevering.
Declining results
- Results have dropped since last term. The consistency shown at the start of the year needs to return.
- Effort has slipped this term. The ability is there; the commitment must come back.
- Results are falling, particularly in written assessments. A real effort is needed.
- A mixed term. Be careful not to let gaps build up.
Inconsistent results
- Results go up and down. More regular work would help to stabilise them.
- Good successes alternate with weaker assessments. Preparation needs to be more consistent.
- Results vary from one topic to another. The less secure concepts need reviewing.
Frequently absent or returning after an absence
- Frequent absences make assessment difficult. Missed lessons need to be caught up.
- A term disrupted by absences. Missed content should be revisited as a priority.
- Not enough assessments this term to judge the work fairly.
Adapting the comment to the time of year
The same situation is not written the same way in December and in June. In the first term, you set things up; in the second, you take stock; in the third, you wrap up and look ahead.
First term: building habits
- A good start to the year, which now needs to be confirmed. Working methods are taking shape.
- A difficult start to the year. Good work habits need to be established now.
- Has settled well into the new level. Continue with the same consistency.
- An encouraging first term. The expectations of the class are understood.
Second term: taking stock
- This term confirms the strengths seen earlier. The aim now is greater rigour.
- Progress since the first term. It needs to continue to finish the year with confidence.
- A step back this term. There is still time to react before the end of the year.
- A steady term. The weaknesses identified at the start of the year still need work.
Third term: wrapping up and looking ahead
- A successful year, rounded off with a solid term. All the best for next year.
- This year's progress is real. It will need keeping up over the summer.
- A difficult year. This year's basics will need consolidating before tackling the next.
- A fine achievement. The qualities shown this year will be an asset in the years ahead.
Examples by subject
Naming a skill specific to the subject is often enough to make a comment more useful. A few examples of targeted wording:
| Subject | Strength | Area for improvement |
|---|---|---|
| Maths | Reasoning is rigorous and well justified. | Calculations need checking: too many careless errors. |
| English | Text analysis is perceptive and well argued. | Spelling and sentence structure still hold back written work. |
| History and geography | Knowledge is secure and key dates and places are known. | Extended answers need to be better organised. |
| Physics and chemistry | The experimental approach is well mastered. | Units and significant figures need more care. |
| Biology | Diagrams are precise and well labelled. | Observations need to be linked more closely to what was taught. |
| World languages | Speaking is becoming more fluent and spontaneous. | Vocabulary needs to be learned more regularly. |
| Philosophy | Questions are well framed and examples relevant. | Arguments need more depth and nuance. |
| PE | Consistent commitment and visible technical progress. | Effort needs to be sustained throughout the unit. |
Phrases to avoid
- Judgments about the person: “lazy”, “insolent”, “not cut out for school”. Describe a behaviour or a piece of work, never a character.
- Empty comments: “Satisfactory overall”, “Could do better” and nothing else. They say neither what nor how.
- Comparisons between students: “below the class average” does not help a student improve.
- Final verdicts: “will never reach the level”. A report card may be read when decisions about a student's path are made years later.
- Contradictions: glowing praise above an average of 7 out of 20, or the reverse, puzzles families.
- Private information: health, family circumstances or a detailed disciplinary incident have no place in a subject comment.
Using AI to write report card comments
Asking a chatbot to suggest wording is tempting, and useful for varying your style. One rule applies, though: in France, the framework for the use of AI in education published by the Ministry of Education in June 2025 states that no personal data may be entered into a consumer AI service. A named report card, a class list or grades attached to names all count as personal data.
- Ask for wording, not report cards: “suggest five comments for a hard-working student whose written work is slipping” contains no personal data.
- Give anonymous facts: a profile (“results improving, little participation, difficulties with calculation”) is enough to get a targeted suggestion.
- Reread every sentence: the comment is still yours, and you are the one who signs it in front of the student and their family.
Starting from the papers graded during the term
The fairest comments are based on what the student actually produced. If you grade your tests with Correxio, every paper already gets two or three sentences of feedback and remarks placed exactly where they apply on the paper, which you have reviewed and adjusted. When report cards come round, that feedback and the scores per question show at a glance what is improving and what is holding the student back: all that is left is to sum it up.
The student's name is hidden before the AI reads the paper, the data is hosted in France (security and GDPR), and grades can be exported as CSV or as a sheet ready to paste into Pronote, the school management software used in France.
In short
A good report card comment fits in two sentences: a specific observation, a word about the work, advice for what comes next. The examples above give you a starting point, to personalise with a fact drawn from the student's papers. And if an AI helps you find the words, it should receive no data that identifies a student, and the final read-through remains the teacher's.